The political landscape in New Hampshire is currently fraught with tension as a significant rift has emerged concerning the potential third term for Business and Economic Affairs Commissioner Taylor Caswell. This public division, which has been simmering for an extended period, recently reached a boiling point when Governor Kelly Ayotte temporarily halted Caswell’s re-nomination, signaling a deep-seated disagreement within the state’s leadership.
At the heart of this controversy are three of the four Republican members of the Executive Council, who have explicitly stated their unwillingness to endorse Caswell’s continued tenure as the state’s primary business recruiter. Their opposition underscores a notable challenge to the Governor’s choices and highlights divergent views on economic strategy and leadership effectiveness within the state government.
Conversely, a strong coalition of supporters vigorously defends Caswell’s qualifications and performance, lauding him as a dynamic administrator possessing over three decades of diverse experience across both private and public sectors. These advocates, including prominent figures like Hughes and Stevens, emphasize Caswell’s unwavering commitment to fostering New Hampshire’s economic vitality, attracting new businesses, and expanding existing ones amidst a period of considerable national economic uncertainty.
Governor Ayotte, privately expressing reservations to councilors, has voiced concerns about the timing of such a leadership transition within the Department of Business and Economic Affairs, citing the pressing challenges confronting the nation’s economy. Caswell himself recently highlighted a 30% decrease in entries from Canadian businesses into New Hampshire and ongoing anxieties within the business community regarding potential tariffs from the Trump administration, reinforcing the argument against destabilizing leadership at this critical juncture.
Despite his supporters’ endorsements, Caswell has faced pointed critiques regarding his departmental spending and strategic decisions. Councilor Dave Wheeler, for instance, openly rejected several of Caswell’s requests, including funding for a $150,000 business conference and a contract for a videographer that he deemed excessive, pointing out that some services could have been secured pro bono. Wheeler also controversially labeled aspects of the $100 million InvestNH Housing program as “corporate welfare,” indicating fundamental policy disagreements.
Taylor Caswell’s extensive career in public service dates back to 1992, beginning as a legislative director for former U.S. Rep. Bill Zeliff. His journey continued with significant roles, including regional administrator for the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under former President George W. Bush, before he led the New Hampshire Community Development Finance Authority. He became the inaugural commissioner of the Department of Business and Economic Affairs when then-Governor Chris Sununu established the agency in 2017.
Even some former supporters, like Councilor Joe Kenney, who previously voted for Caswell twice, are now withholding their support for a third term. Kenney contends that Caswell has allowed neighboring states to surpass New Hampshire in innovation and economic growth. He specifically highlighted an imbalance in marketing funds, noting that only $50,000 is allocated for business promotion compared to $14 million for travel and tourism, and criticized the lack of support for the vital forestry industry.
In his earnest plea to retain his position, Caswell underscored his ongoing efforts to complete the Business Gateway, a groundbreaking online portal designed to centralize state services, filings, reports, and technical assistance for all companies. This initiative, he argues, is crucial for maintaining New Hampshire’s competitive edge. Caswell expressed optimism for the state’s continued economic success, affirming his dedication to the “Live Free or Die” state’s mission.
The public drama surrounding Caswell’s re-nomination reflects a deeper struggle over New Hampshire’s economic direction and leadership stability. With key councilors, including John Stephen, making decisive votes, the outcome will significantly shape the state’s approach to business attraction and retention. This political standoff underscores the complexities of governance and the critical need for alignment to ensure robust economic progress.
