The contentious confirmation of Brian Burch as the United States Ambassador to the Holy See marks a significant moment in US diplomacy, bringing a prominent conservative voice and critic of Pope Francis into a key diplomatic role. Burch, a seasoned figure in American Catholic circles and co-founder of CatholicVote, now steps onto the global stage during a complex period for both US foreign policy and Vatican relations.
Known for his outspoken criticisms of the current pontiff, Burch’s appointment has drawn considerable attention. He previously voiced concerns regarding Pope Francis’ss 2023 decision to allow blessings for individuals in same-sex unions, suggesting it created “confusion” within the church. Such public disagreements highlight a tension between conservative Catholic viewpoints and the more progressive stances adopted by elements within the Vatican.
Further fueling his reputation as a formidable critic, Burch also took issue with Pope Francis’s disciplinary actions, specifically the removal of Texas Bishop Joseph Strickland, a conservative cleric known for clashing with the Vatican. Burch characterized this action as a “pattern of vindictiveness and punishment,” which he argued contradicted the Pope’s stated emphasis on mercy and accompaniment, underscoring deep ideological divisions.
His past remarks extend to a 2015 comment by Pope Francis about Catholics not needing to “breed like rabbits,” a statement the pontiff later apologized for. This particular criticism holds personal resonance for Burch, who is a father of nine children, illustrating how his personal convictions often align with his public advocacy for traditional Catholic teachings.
CatholicVote, the influential advocacy group co-founded by Burch, has played a pivotal role in American political discourse, notably through its active support for Donald Trump in both the 2020 and 2024 presidential elections. The organization has employed aggressive campaign tactics, including a controversial 30-second advertisement alleging that a vote for then-Vice President Biden was a vote for “medical experiments on kids,” a reference to gender-affirming care.
Following his confirmation, Brian Burch expressed profound gratitude to Donald Trump and the United States Senate for the opportunity to serve, a sentiment that aligns with CatholicVote’s unwavering backing of the former president. His statement underscored his honor and privilege in assuming this significant role, indicating a strong alignment with the Trump Administration’s approach to international relations.
The confirmation has been met with positive reactions from his allies. CatholicVote itself celebrated the news, emphasizing Burch’s 17 years of dedicated service to their mission of inspiring American Catholics to engage faith in public life, expressing confidence in his future success. The University of Dallas also extended congratulations to their alumnus, acknowledging his achievement and wishing him well in Rome.
This appointment positions Brian Burch at the nexus of religious diplomacy and US foreign policy, carrying the weight of his conservative stances and his organization’s political activities into his ambassadorial duties. His tenure will undoubtedly be watched closely for its implications on the relationship between Washington and the Holy See, particularly as it navigates ongoing cultural and political shifts within Catholicism globally. The integration of a vocal figure like Burch into this delicate diplomatic arena suggests a period of potentially dynamic engagement between the US and the Vatican.
