Former Scottish National Party (SNP) Member of Parliament, Mhairi Black, has offered a compelling and at times, startling, account of Nicola Sturgeon’s formidable presence within UK politics during her tenure as First Minister. Black’s candid revelations paint a picture of a leader whose impact was undeniable, yet whose leadership style fostered an environment of apprehension among her own ranks.
According to Ms. Black, Sturgeon’s visits to Westminster generated a palpable sense of fear among her parliamentary colleagues. The mere knowledge of her presence would “spread like wildfire,” causing noticeable disquiet. This insight underscores the immense power and authority Ms. Sturgeon commanded, creating an atmosphere where even seasoned politicians felt “absolutely terrified” when in her vicinity.
Despite these observations about her imposing demeanor, Ms. Black readily acknowledged Nicola Sturgeon’s exceptional political acumen. She described Sturgeon as “possibly the best politician” in the United Kingdom, specifically praising her remarkable composure and communication skills. This recognition highlights Sturgeon’s unique ability to articulate complex messages and maintain a composed front under intense scrutiny, hallmarks of effective political leadership.
However, Ms. Black’s commentary extends beyond mere personal observations to include pointed criticisms regarding the internal mechanics and evolution of the SNP politics under Sturgeon’s direction. Black asserted that the party’s structure had “never grown or adapted” throughout Sturgeon’s leadership, implying a stagnation that ultimately failed to keep pace with the evolving demands of its membership and the broader Scottish leadership landscape.
These criticisms come amidst Ms. Black’s recent disclosure of her departure from the SNP, driven by profound dissatisfaction with the party’s trajectory. Her decision to step down from parliament ahead of the general election and sever ties with the party signals a significant internal dissent, offering a rare glimpse into the challenges faced by the UK Westminster establishment from within.
A primary factor in Ms. Black’s decision to leave was the party’s perceived “capitulation” on LGBT rights and trans rights. This stance, she argued, was a major point of contention, leading her to conclude that other organizations might better align with her values and receive her membership. This reveals a critical issue within the party’s internal reform efforts, impacting its progressive credentials.
Further adding to her compelling narrative, Ms. Black did not shy away from commenting on other prominent figures, notably describing one as “the British Trump.” This provocative comparison, labeling the individual as “Poisonous” and a “millionaire in a cravat,” showcases Ms. Black’s characteristic bluntness and her broader disillusionment with certain aspects of contemporary political discourse.
Having served as Deputy Leader of the SNP in the House of Commons from 2022 to 2024, Mhairi Black’s insights are drawn from direct experience. Her decision to stand down from her parliamentary role was also influenced by personal safety concerns, social media abuse, and the unsociable hours inherent in a demanding political career, underscoring the multifaceted pressures faced by public figures.
